"Are Emotions Evaluative Modes ?"

Article publié par Jérôme Dokic et Stéphane Lemaire dans la revue scientifique Dialectica "Following Meinong, many philosophers have been attracted by the view that emotions have intrinsically evaluative correctness conditions".

extrait de la page de la revue en ligne Dialectica


On one version of this view, emotions have evaluative contents (the Perception View). On another version, emotions are evaluative attitudes; they are evaluative at the level of intentional mode rather than content (the Attitudinal View). We raise objections against the latter version, showing that the only two ways of implementing it are hopeless. Either emotions are manifestly evaluative or they are not. In the former case, the Attitudinal View threatens to collapse into the Perception View or any other view according to which emotions are evaluative at the level of content. In the latter case, the Attitudinal View does not stand up to an obvious alternative, namely that emotions can only be assessed with respect to extrinsic (moral, prudential, aesthetical, etc.) norms or conditions of correctness.

Special Issue: Beyond Perceptualism
Volume 69, Issue 3, pages 271–292, September 2015